According to MoneyGeek, most burglaries in 2023 occurred at residential properties, typically late at night. That means the average home is more vulnerable than many people realize. If someone else has access to your keys, or if your locks haven’t been updated in years, your security may already be compromised, putting your family at risk.
Whether you’ve just moved in or lost a key, you might be wondering: when it comes to rekeying locks vs replacing them, which makes more sense?
In this guide, you’ll learn exactly when to choose each option, how they compare in cost and effectiveness, and what steps to take next to keep your home secure. Keep reading to learn more.
How to Decide Between Rekeying and Replacing
The right solution depends on why you’re changing your locks in the first place. Each option solves a different type of problem.
When Should You Rekey?
Choose rekeying if your primary concern is controlling who has access, without replacing hardware that still works. Rekeying changes the internal configuration of the lock so old keys no longer work. Consider this option if:
- Your keys were lost, stolen, or copied
- You just moved into a new home and want to control access
- You want one key to open multiple locks
- Your locks are still in good shape
Although most standard pin tumbler locks can be rekeyed, some types, like certain wafer locks or tubular locks, cannot. Rekeyed locks are just as durable as new ones if your hardware is still in good condition. With regular maintenance, most residential locks will usually last from 7 to 10 years.
When Should You Replace Locks?
Replacing your locks is the better choice when:
- They show visible signs of wear, damage, or malfunction
- You want to upgrade to higher-security options such as smart locks or heavy-duty deadbolts
- You need locks that match new door hardware or design preferences
If you’re unsure which option is best, Austin locksmith services can assess your needs and recommend the safest, most affordable home security solutions tailored to your requirements.
How to Choose the Right Replacement Locks
Start by identifying your security needs. For basic protection, standard deadbolts are effective and affordable. If you’re upgrading security, look for ANSI Grade 1 or Grade 2 locks, which meet higher strength and durability standards.
Always check that the lock is compatible with your door’s thickness and material.
Comparing Rekeying vs Replacing Costs
Comparing the costs of rekeying and replacing can help you find the most practical option. Here’s a quick breakdown.
Rekeying Costs
Rekeying focuses solely on changing the internal pins of your current locks. Here’s what you can expect:
- Labor costs range from $20 to $50 per lock
- No hardware costs
- Savings when multiple locks are rekeyed in one visit
- Completion time of about 30 to 60 minutes per lock
Replacing Costs
Replacing involves installing completely new locks. Costs include:
- New hardware and labor fees, typically $50 to $150 for standard locks
- Higher prices for advanced or smart locks, often $200 or more
Installation time and locksmith fees vary, so always get a detailed estimate before committing.
DIY or Professional Locksmith: What’s Best
Rekeying or replacing locks may be possible for those with some DIY experience and the right tools. However, it is easy to make mistakes that could cause problems down the line, such as:
- Improper installation: Locks not installed correctly can jam, malfunction, or fail to secure the door properly
- Damaging the lock or door: Forcing parts or using the wrong tools can damage delicate lock components or even door frames
- Reduced security: Incorrect rekeying may leave old keys working or create vulnerabilities that can be exploited
- Voiding warranties: DIY work might void manufacturer warranties on locks or hardware
- Incompatibility issues: Choosing the wrong lock type or size can cause fitment problems or reduce effectiveness
Licensed locksmiths have the tools and expertise to handle all lock types, including high-security systems that require precise work.
Finding a Locksmith in San Marcos, Round Rock, and Surrounds
Choosing the right locksmith means focusing on what matters most for your security and convenience. Here’s what to keep in mind:
- Identify the service you need, such as rekeying, lock replacement, or emergency lockout help
- Verify they are licensed, bonded, and insured to protect your property and guarantee professional standards
- Check recent customer reviews to confirm reliability and service quality
- Ask for transparent, upfront pricing before any work begins
- Look for an Austin Metro locksmith who provides mobile services for same-day on-site assistance
- Choose one who operates with fast response times and flexible hours, including weekends
How to Maintain Your Locks
Keeping your locks in good condition helps extend their lifespan and ensures your home stays secure. Follow these practical tips.
Clean Locks Regularly
Dirt and dust can build up inside locks, causing them to stick or malfunction. Wipe the exterior with a soft cloth and avoid harsh chemicals that might damage the lock.
While cleaning, also check for wear, corrosion, or loose parts that could affect lock performance.
Lubricate Periodically
Use a graphite-based or silicone spray lubricant to keep the lock mechanism smooth. Avoid oil-based lubricants as they can attract dirt and grime over time.
Use Keys Gently
Do not twist or force keys. It can break the key or damage the lock pins.
Protect Outdoor Locks
Exposure to weather can cause rust and damage, shortening the lock’s lifespan and reliability. Use covers to protect them throughout the year.
Rekeying Locks vs Replacing: Making the Right Choice
Ultimately, the choice between rekeying locks vs replacing depends on your specific situation. Both options offer distinct advantages, so assess your current security risks and consider how each aligns with your long-term needs and budget.
Since 2010, Pros On Call has delivered locksmith and garage door services backed by licensed, insured technicians and fast response times across Austin, San Antonio, and Dallas. We combine family-owned values with modern security solutions to protect what matters most. Serving both residential and commercial customers, we offer transparent pricing and an easy online request system.
Contact us today for service you can trust.
